Alliance Theatre, 2008
Doubt' showcases a remarkable company of actors... Mantella exploits the potential of her character's naivete with finely calibrated timing, so that Sister James' meltdown is richly comic.
— Wendell Brock, Atlanta Journal-Constitution
It's a joy to praise this outstanding cast... Cara Mantella balances the piece beautifully with a wonderful, comic vivaciousness and sincerity; she's a gem.
— Manning Harris, Atlanta INTown, In The Loop
the nuanced performances are top-notch... Mantella (“The Last Night of Ballyhoo") has never been better.
— Bert Osborne, The Sunday Paper
Mantella's Sister James turns out to be an unexpectedly important character. She provides not just welcome comic relief but a surrogate for the audience...
— Curt Holman, Creative Loafing